raghav
Monday, February 22, 2010
Things you should know about B-Schools in India
Total Number of test takers – CAT 2009: 226546
In total less than 1% of the population who takes the test gets a GD-PI call and only around 0.6% people finally make it to the IIMs.
Harvard Business School had 8661 applications in 2008. It admitted 900 candidates. 12% made it to Harvard. Almost all top Schools around the world admit approximately 10% or more of the total applications received. Even ISB Hyderabad, which has admitted 579 students for 2009-10 has a close to 10% acceptance record.
In India things are different. For about 240 seats at XLRI over 80,000 students wrote the entrance test in 2009. Tests like SNAP and NMAT also boast of over 50,000 applications.
The good thing about Indian B-schools is the fees. Even though most B-schools have increased fees by 75%-100% in the last 2 years in India, by all standards the financial burden is still very less compared to most B-schools abroad or even ISB hyderbabad.
The tests are not error-free
For 3 years in a row we have seen errors in the CAT paper. Students spend crucial time trying to solve a question which is wrong. It’s amazing almost no MBA entrance exam is error free! Invariably, there is an error. Actually, we should be thankful that these can be pointed out now because the question booklet is allowed to be retained by the test taker. Previously, the booklets would go back with the answer sheet. You would only know your final score/Percentile assuming that the question paper was error free. Sometimes, the paper may be error free but the answer keys may be wrong! Everyone knows what happened with the Snap Test in 2008. This was the first time they gave back the question booklet and hence, students could point out the mistakes due to wide discrepancy between the marks they should have got and the marks shown by the SNAP test scorecard.
I must tell you though that after the GMAT you directly get the score/Percentile. You cannot verify whether the answers were correct. You do not even know which questions you answered correctly and which ones you did not. You have to assume that the software and the GMAC are very competent and they will not make a mistake. Transparency is difficult because there are multiple tests and different people take those tests at different times. There is a chance of overlap of questions.
Placement figures are not verified by any independent agency
Most students join B-schools based on Placements. Most rankings focus on that. Most advertisements of newer B-schools talk about placements. The Indian Media is obsessed with placements. However, there is not a single B-school in India to the best of my knowledge that gets it’s placement process and figures verified by an external independent agency. Even the T.I.M.E institute gets its results/calls verified by KPMG.
There have been many instances where students have been fooled into joining a new B-school by advertisements that promise great placements. Only after joining they discover that the actual figures are miles away from the advertised ones.
Even students in esteemed institutions like the IIMs and XLRI claim privately that in order to keep their reputation intact official placement figures are manipulated in a way that suits them. No B-school in India barring maybe ISB discloses median salary. Mean salary can be very misleading. Of course I don’t have any proof that the B-schools abroad are 100% honest but prima facie the information they disclose seems very authentic.
Short listing and selection criteria are subject to change anytime and it comes out only after the test is over!
Most IIMs disclose the criteria for short listing only after the test (CAT) is over. It changes every year and depending on the test the IIMs tweak their criteria. Let me explain how it affects students. 2007 CAT results were announced and students discovered that IIM Indore has given calls to people with percentile as low as 85 as long as their overall percentile is high. IIM Lucknow announced a 60% weightage to overall CAT score/percentile and a cutoff of 85 percentile per section. All this after the test was over! A genuine student would have tried to balance all 3 sections to get a 90+ in all or 95+ not looking at the overall Percentile and score. It may so happen that he would have got decent sectional scores but low overall score. But the IIMs called people who had screwed up one/two sections but had done very well overall! Fine, if this is your criteria at least disclose it before the test so that students can strategise! Chance does play a role in the current scheme of things. You have to keep your fingers crossed so that the IIMs decide upon a criterion that suits you!
Another example is the sudden introduction of Xth, XIIth and graduation marks in the selection process. Again, fine you want to introduce it. But at least tell us beforehand. There are some people who suddenly get shocks after the result. In spite of getting 99.5+ percentiles overall they still end up missing calls whereas people with 98.xx make it. In IIM B’s case even people with 95 may make it. (To be fair to IIM B though they have always maintained they take into account academic scores.)
Even other Indian B-schools do this. IIMs are not the only ones guilty. IMI Delhi tried doing it. There was a student outrage over it. They reverted to old.
Normalisation of Xth, XIIth and graduation scores is a mystery
Even when Xth/XIIth and graduation scores are taken into account, it is still a mystery whether normalization is done. Normalization means the process of bringing at par scores of various boards, streams and universities. Typically marking schemes of most boards in a country as diverse as India are very varied.
Now everyone knows in cities like Mumbai, that Commerce/Science/Arts marking schemes are very different. The IIMs compare them at par. They can’t have an explanation for this as they have no clue whether the person did his junior college in Commerce/Science/Arts. Reason: they don’t ask for it in the form! They only ask grad stream which may be different from 12th STD.
IIM B claims they normalize the scores. We will never know this. They will never reveal data that they have so you cannot be sure whether it was done. You will only know your score. Other IIMs don’t even claim to do it. IIM A has not done it this year (CAT 2008). I have a letter from them which they sent under RTI. IIM L also does not normalize. It is almost impossible for any Mumbai University engineer to get into IIM Shillong.
So basically, if your mum and dad put you in a board which follows a lower marking pattern you are bound to be doomed. I think the IIMs want people to start planning 20 years in advance if they want to send their children to IIM.
This is also true of other B-schools of India except SPJain who take into account academics.
Most B-school rankings are a farce
There is not too much debate on this issue. Anyone who has followed B-school rankings of different agencies and publications in India will tell you that these rankings are very misleading. Most of them are unscientific and tend to promote some or the other B-School.
Reservations
Lesser said the better. In due course of time IIMs will have a batch with 50% reserved category applicants. The number of open category seats will remain unchanged though. Private B-schools do not have reservations yet. But some good B-schools indulge in Management quotas in order to make some more money.
Diversity and Female candidates
There is no diversity in Indian B-schools. Most have above 80% engineers. Some even have about 92-93% engineers. Girls form not more than 5-8% of the batch at the IIMs. Ratio is better at Private B-schools. This is due to less number of females applying (50,000 approx out of 246546 in 2008) and need to disclose selection criteria. One of the IIM directors has publicly admitted that previously they used to fuzz the results to get in more girls. A lot of tinkering done with the CAT test and the selection criteria in 2008 was to improve the female: male ratio. ISB Hyderabad due to a subjective process has about 28% of females in the batch. SPJain , MICA(close to 50%) and XLRI are other B-schools with relatively better female: male ratios. SPJain and MICA(due to the programme itself) have a better non-engineering students percentage too.
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Mass discrepancies in IIT admissions
Despite good scores, students fail to make it
Source: Tribune News Service
Venkatraman Ramakrishnan may have won a Nobel for Chemistry, but he was never good enough to crack the IIT-JEE. The scientist was perhaps one among the hundreds who, year after year, lose their IIT dream despite top scores in the JEE of a given year.
Strangely for them, others with scores much lower than their own make it to the institutes, courtesy a heavily faulted and non-fixed procedure of fixing cut-off marks for math, physics and chemistry, which determine a student’s eligibility for admission to IITs.
For the first time since decades of secrecy around the IIT system, large-scale discrepancy in admissions to institutes has surfaced, following efforts of Prof Rajeev Kumar, a faculty at IIT Kharagpur, who has brought the mass bungling to government’s notice.
Shocking disclosures (from 2006 to 2009) he procured from IITs under the RTI are now in the knowledge of HRD Minister Kapil Sibal, who will meet the professor tomorrow to discuss the matter. The documents show how 994 top scoring students failed to make it to IITs in 2006 just because cut off calculations that year were faulted.
Picture this: A 2006 IIT-JEE aspirant with a cumulative score of 251 (101 in math; 96 physics; 54 chemistry) was disqualified for admission whereas another with a low score of 154 (37 math; 48 physics; 69 chemistry) scraped through. A top JEE 2006 scorer with 279 marks (36 math; 116 physics and 127 chemistry) was rejected against another who scored a meager 156 (45 math; 56 physics and 55 chemistry).
Reason: Top scorers in JEE 2006 failed to secure cut-off marks prescribed by IITs in either of the three subjects - 37, 48 and 55, respectively, for maths, physics and chemistry, respectively. Consequently, a student who had a high score of 101 in Math and 96 in Physics was disqualified that year only because he missed the Chemistry cut off by one mark, scoring 54 instead of the required 55.
What’s shocking, however, is this: Cut off calculations for IIT-JEE 2006 which Prof Rajeev Kumar did on the basis of the criteria which IITs disclosed under the RTI yielded much lower minimum scores for the three subjects than what the IITs had claimed. Actual cut offs came out to be 7, 4 and 6, respectively, for math, physics and chemistry as against 37, 48, and 55, respectively, which IITs followed that year for admissions.
“The IITs then supplied many versions of the subject cut-off procedure (which to date is not fixed and keeps changing), none could correctly explain the stated cut offs used in 2006,” Kumar stated today in his letter to the President of India, IITs and to Sibal.
Kumar’s theory of IIT 2006 admissions being based on erroneous calculations gains ground considering unimaginable declines in subsequent JEE cut-offs — 4, 1 and 3, respectively, in 2007; 5, 0 and 3 in 2008 and 11, 8 and 11 in 2009, respectively for math, physics and chemistry. Equally inexplicable is the wide variation in cut off marks over years - in 2008, cut off for Physics was 0; it was 48 in 2006.
Documents further show that in JEEs (2007 to 2009), students with as low as 5 per cent marks (one scored just 8 marks in physics; the cut off was 0) were declared qualified. However, students with as high as 29 per cent marks in any one subject were rejected. The most shocking case involves a student who, with as less as 10 per cent marks in math (just 16) in JEE 2009 was placed at a high All-India rank of 1234, enabling him entry to any IIT. The trend is obviously in contrast to the IIT policy of fishing the best talent with basic knowledge of the three subjects.
The RTI has also exposed instances of wrong evaluation of question papers by IITs which still don’t share JEE results on the day of the test. Before the test, they seek from students a declaration saying: “Admission irregularities can’t be challenged”. RTI documents with Kumar have revealed that in IIT-JEE 2006, questions worth 11 marks were wrongly evaluated. In 2008, a candidate with 10 marks in math qualified for admissions, whereas math questions worth 18 marks were wrongly evaluated
Thursday, November 26, 2009
26/11, No more hatred please.....
As a human being I salute all those who have empathy and love in their hearts. The police and commandos who fought for those they didn’t even know. The staff at the Taj, Trident and CST station. I salute the people who were at the attacked spots, including reporters. I salute those who stayed up during those 60 hours and watched the news. I salute all those who wept for what was lost that day. Most of all, I salute all those who lost their lives that day. As much as lives, there was a loss of religion and a country too, on that 26th of November. And most of all, there was the loss of humanity.
Tuesday, August 25, 2009
Jump on and live a Eurorail journey you will never forget!.

Before Sunrise deals with the moment of the chance encounter --- the accidental meeting of someone, making a connection, and then taking a risk and getting to know them. Jesse & Celine meet on a train, and Jesse persuades Celine to make an unplanned stop with him in Vienna to keep him company in the afternoon and evening before he has to catch a plane. The two get to know each other, and what starts out as a chance encounter turns into something magical.
What strikes me about both movies is that they are hyper-real. Before Sunset is shot almost entirely in real time, with no skipped moments. There are moments in my life when I've felt every moment in complete intensity, and the movies reflect those moments fluidly. I remember the arm wrapping move as Julie Depry puts her arms around Ethan Hawke vividly in Before Sunrise, and there's a moment in the van when she reaches out to touch him but draws back as he turns to look at her --- those moments in the film are so real that they cannot be defined in a better way.
Before Sunset is about the "what if". What if you had made choices differently? What if when you were young and stupid you would have been just a little less stupid? By aging the actors naturally (9 years pass between the first and second movies) there is no contrivance at all in the changes over the years. I especially enjoyed the expression one of the characters made in saying, essentially, "When I was young I had so many choices I threw them away without realizing the preciousness of what I had thrown away." Yet the movies aren't full of regrets, and each movie ends with a question mark.
OK, I will not spoil the movies for you. Go watch it, and don't read any other reviews before watching them. Listen to each and every dialogue and all you need will be love.
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
We are RACISTs too......
One can see racism in Indian mythology too. "When Krishna literally means dark then why is he always portrayed in blue rather than in natural black?" Comics and TV serials routinely depict evil (the demons) as dark and good (the gods) as fair.
The South Indians have always been looked down by the northeners and are being called as tourists and Madrasis.Tamil cinema is known for reinforcing the fact against dark skin. Superhero Rajnikanth himself may be dark, but fair women all the way from Haryana are imported to star in Tamil films.
The people who really want reservation are the ones who lie below poverty line.The World Bank estimates that 42% of the total Indian population now live under the global poverty line. This means that a third of the global poor now reside in India. And just to remind you, the global poverty line is a mere 1.5$ per day.(Purchase Power Parity) I think that the way we treat dark-skinned people isn't racism but a reflection of how unaware a large section of Indians are. Fair people are just better accepted in our society. Only we cn change this myth. I found the following information on the net about the rasicm prevelant in our society. Indian Style
|